Scottish Parliament – Feb. 22, 2023 – 3
Launching a Successful Deposit Return Scheme (Amendment 1)
Result
❌ Motion failed.
Aye: 58 MSPs
No: 65 MSPs
Absent: 7 MSPs
Parliamentary analysis
Strong conflict: Opposition proposesThis vote is most similar to a group of votes where the opposition has proposed a motion and the government is strongly opposing it (few defections, high turnout).
This usually suggests an important point of principle, or that it would have substantive effects if passed.
Motion
Motion type: Amendment(?)
S6M-07975.1: As an amendment to motion S6M-07975 in the name of Maurice Golden (Launching a Successful Deposit Return Scheme), insert at end “;
acknowledges that an effective modern deposit return scheme reduces carbon emissions and waste;
welcomes the changes that have been made to the proposals since the regulations were first made;
recognises that concerns from some businesses, in particular small producers and retailers, remain over operational elements of the scheme, and urges the Scottish Government to consider further changes ahead of any introduction, including a grace period for small producers, exemptions for low volume producers, and an opt-in for small retailers to ensure delivery of a viable Deposit Return Scheme that helps meet Scotland’s net zero ambitions.”
Original motion(S6M-07975): That the Parliament believes that a Deposit Return Scheme (DRS) can make a positive contribution to increasing the rate of recycling and reducing litter for drinks containers;
recognises that the Scottish Government has been committed to introducing a DRS since 2013;
welcomes the widespread support that the scheme’s environmental objectives have received from businesses, and recognises their concerns over key operational elements of the scheme;
understands that businesses, and waste management experts have called for at least 18 months’ notice prior to the scheme launch, and that, with less than six months until the proposed launch, information is still required by stakeholders to both ensure compliance and maximise the operational success of the scheme;
notes the findings of the Gateway Review Final Report, which stated that “…a fully functioning and compliant DRS cannot be in operation for the revised August 2023 schedule”, and calls for an urgent independent review of the launch date to enable a successful launch as soon as practically possible.
Annotations
No annotations for this decision.
Whip reports
No whip reports for this decision.
Overall counts
| Grouping | MSPs on date | Vote participant count | For motion | Against motion | Absent motion | Turnout | For motion percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All MSPs | 130 | 123 | 58 | 65 | 7 | 94.62% | 47.15% |
Government counts
| Grouping | MSPs on date | Vote participant count | For motion | Against motion | Absent motion | Turnout | For motion percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opposition | 58 | 57 | 57 | 0 | 1 | 98.28% | 100.00% |
| Government | 72 | 66 | 1 | 65 | 6 | 91.67% | 1.52% |
Party voting counts
| Grouping | MSPs on date | Vote participant count | For motion | Against motion | Absent motion | Party turnout | For motion percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Scottish National Party | 64 | 59 | 1 | 58 | 5 | 92.19% | 1.69% |
| Labour | 23 | 22 | 22 | 0 | 1 | 95.65% | 100.00% |
| Liberal Democrat | 4 | 4 | 4 | 0 | 0 | 100.00% | 100.00% |
| Conservative | 31 | 31 | 31 | 0 | 0 | 100.00% | 100.00% |
| Green | 8 | 7 | 0 | 7 | 1 | 87.50% | 0.00% |
Voting list
| Person | Party | Vote | Party alignment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Foysol Choudhury | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Russell Findlay | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Michael Matheson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Craig Hoy | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Michael Marra | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Audrey Nicoll | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Mark Ruskell | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Mairi Gougeon | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Pam Gosal | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Shona Robison | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Sue Webber | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Maree Todd | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Ariane Burgess | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Graham Simpson | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Emma Harper | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Willie Coffey | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| John Swinney | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Kaukab Stewart | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Keith Brown | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Joe FitzPatrick | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Pam Duncan-Glancy | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Miles Briggs | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Angus Robertson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Paul Sweeney | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Carol Mochan | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Meghan Gallacher | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Evelyn Tweed | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Stephen Kerr | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Bob Doris | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Ruth Maguire | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Alison Johnstone | Green | Absent | n/a |
| Colin Beattie | Scottish National Party | Absent | n/a |
| Sandesh Gulhane | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ivan McKee | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Murdo Fraser | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Marie McNair | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| George Adam | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Annie Wells | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Christina McKelvie | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| John Mason | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jamie Halcro Johnston | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Paul McLennan | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Ash Denham | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Willie Rennie | Liberal Democrat | Aye | 100.00% |
| Sarah Boyack | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ross Greer | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Jim Fairlie | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| James Dornan | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Fergus Ewing | Scottish National Party | Aye | 1.69% |
| Natalie Don | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Mercedes Villalba | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Gillian Martin | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Beatrice Wishart | Liberal Democrat | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ben Macpherson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Tom Arthur | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jackie Baillie | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Humza Yousaf | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Roz McCall | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Annabelle Ewing | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Donald Cameron | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Graeme Dey | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jackie Dunbar | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Fiona Hyslop | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Fulton MacGregor | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Kate Forbes | Scottish National Party | Absent | n/a |
| Clare Haughey | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Rachael Hamilton | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Shirley-Anne Somerville | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Collette Stevenson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Gordon MacDonald | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jenni Minto | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Siobhian Brown | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Bill Kidd | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Elena Whitham | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Clare Adamson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Kevin Stewart | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| David Torrance | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Patrick Harvie | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Anas Sarwar | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Paul O'Kane | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Richard Lochhead | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Alex Rowley | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Mark Griffin | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Stuart McMillan | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Alexander Burnett | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Liam McArthur | Liberal Democrat | Aye | 100.00% |
| Daniel Johnson | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Stephanie Callaghan | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jamie Hepburn | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Karen Adam | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Maurice Golden | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Claire Baker | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Douglas Lumsden | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Liam Kerr | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Brian Whittle | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alexander Stewart | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Kenneth Gibson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jamie Greene | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Christine Grahame | Scottish National Party | Absent | n/a |
| Davy Russell | Labour | Absent | n/a |
| Nicola Sturgeon | Scottish National Party | Absent | n/a |
| Alex Cole-Hamilton | Liberal Democrat | Aye | 100.00% |
| Edward Mountain | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Tess White | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Neil Bibby | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Baroness Clark | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Elizabeth Smith | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jackson Carlaw | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Rona Mackay | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Pauline McNeill | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alasdair Allan | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jenny Gilruth | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Martin Whitfield | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Rhoda Grant | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Maggie Chapman | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Lorna Slater | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Monica Lennon | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Gillian Mackay | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Colin Smyth | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Emma Roddick | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Jeremy Balfour | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Michelle Thomson | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Sharon Dowey | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Finlay Carson | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Richard Leonard | Labour | Aye | 100.00% |
| Oliver Mundell | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Douglas Ross | Conservative | Aye | 100.00% |
| Neil Gray | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Màiri McAllan | Scottish National Party | No | 98.31% |
| Angela Constance | Scottish National Party | Absent | n/a |