Scottish Parliament – Feb. 17, 2021 – 1

Education

Result

❌ Motion failed.

Aye: 61 MSPs

No: 64 MSPs

Absent: 4 MSPs

Parliamentary analysis

Strong conflict: Gov proposes

This vote is most similar to a group of votes where the government is proposing a motion and the opposition is strongly opposing it (few defections, high turnout).

This usually suggests an important point of principle, that even if the government is likely to win, is a significant public signal of opposition.

Motion

Motion type: Other(?)

S5M-24137: That the Parliament believes that the support, services and decision-making provided by Education Scotland and the SQA have not met the expectations or requirements of hardworking teachers, pupils or parents throughout the disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic;

recalls that serious concerns existed about the performance and structure of these organisations for years before the pandemic struck, including those expressed by Parliament in its resolution on the debate on motion S5M-04920 on 29 March 2017;

considers that there is compelling evidence that neither body is fit for purpose and that they have lost the confidence of teachers, pupils and parents, and therefore calls for substantial reform as part of the recovery of education, with Education Scotland separated into independent inspection and policy functions and the SQA to be grounded in the teaching profession and made more accountable, and expresses concern about the reported involvement of both organisations and the Scottish Government in the ongoing OECD review.

Motion in TheyWorkForYou

Annotations

No annotations for this decision.

Whip reports

No whip reports for this decision.

Overall counts

Grouping MSPs on date Vote participant count For motion Against motion Absent motion Turnout For motion percentage
All MSPs 129 125 61 64 4 96.90% 48.80%

Government counts

Grouping MSPs on date Vote participant count For motion Against motion Absent motion Turnout For motion percentage
Opposition 68 65 1 64 3 95.59% 1.54%
Government 61 60 60 0 1 98.36% 100.00%

Party voting counts

Grouping MSPs on date Vote participant count For motion Against motion Absent motion Party turnout For motion percentage
Liberal Democrat 5 5 0 5 0 100.00% 0.00%
Independent 3 2 1 1 1 66.67% 50.00%
Green 5 5 0 5 0 100.00% 0.00%
Conservative 30 29 0 29 1 96.67% 0.00%
Reform UK 1 1 0 1 0 100.00% 0.00%
Labour 24 23 0 23 1 95.83% 0.00%
Scottish National Party 61 60 60 0 1 98.36% 100.00%

Voting list

Download as CSV

Person Party Vote Party alignment
Kenneth Macintosh Labour Absent n/a
Margaret Mitchell Conservative No 100.00%
Richard Lochhead Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Alasdair Allan Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Ash Denham Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
John Scott Conservative No 100.00%
Miles Briggs Conservative No 100.00%
Maree Todd Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Mark McDonald Independent Aye n/a
Gail Ross Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Dean Lockhart Conservative No 100.00%
James Kelly Labour No 100.00%
Annie Wells Conservative No 100.00%
Alex Neil Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Rachael Hamilton Conservative No 100.00%
Aileen Campbell Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Roseanna Cunningham Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Kenneth Gibson Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Andy Wightman Independent No n/a
Angus MacDonald Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Donald Cameron Conservative No 100.00%
Christine Grahame Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Finlay Carson Conservative No 100.00%
Richard Leonard Labour No 100.00%
Bob Doris Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Fiona Hyslop Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Humza Yousaf Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Willie Coffey Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Claire Baker Labour No 100.00%
Keith Brown Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Monica Lennon Labour No 100.00%
Christina McKelvie Scottish National Party Absent n/a
Liam McArthur Liberal Democrat No 100.00%
Willie Rennie Liberal Democrat No 100.00%
Mark Griffin Labour No 100.00%
Johann Lamont Labour No 100.00%
Mike Rumbles Liberal Democrat No 100.00%
Alex Rowley Labour No 100.00%
Patrick Harvie Green No 100.00%
Mark Ruskell Green No 100.00%
Michelle Ballantyne Reform UK No 100.00%
Shirley-Anne Somerville Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Ivan McKee Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Murdo Fraser Conservative No 100.00%
Bruce Crawford Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Jeane Freeman Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Neil Bibby Labour No 100.00%
Edward Mountain Conservative No 100.00%
Clare Haughey Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Ruth Maguire Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Colin Beattie Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Oliver Mundell Conservative No 100.00%
Tom Mason Conservative No 100.00%
Lewis Macdonald Labour No 100.00%
Fulton MacGregor Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Joan McAlpine Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Gil Paterson Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Ben Macpherson Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Maurice Corry Conservative No 100.00%
Daniel Johnson Labour No 100.00%
Joe FitzPatrick Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Gordon Lindhurst Conservative No 100.00%
Beatrice Wishart Liberal Democrat No 100.00%
Peter Chapman Conservative No 100.00%
Maureen Watt Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Bill Bowman Conservative No 100.00%
Emma Harper Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Ross Greer Green No 100.00%
Graham Simpson Conservative No 100.00%
Rhoda Grant Labour No 100.00%
Alison Harris Conservative No 100.00%
Richard Lyle Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Shona Robison Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Rona Mackay Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Jenny Gilruth Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Adam Tomkins Conservative No 100.00%
Angela Constance Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
George Adam Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
John Finnie Green No 100.00%
Annabelle Ewing Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Alexander Stewart Conservative No 100.00%
Gordon MacDonald Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Stewart Stevenson Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Neil Findlay Labour No 100.00%
Nicola Sturgeon Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Claudia Beamish Labour No 100.00%
Jenny Marra Labour No 100.00%
Jamie Greene Conservative No 100.00%
Brian Whittle Conservative No 100.00%
Iain Gray Labour No 100.00%
Liam Kerr Conservative No 100.00%
Paul Wheelhouse Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Michael Russell Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Fergus Ewing Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
James Dornan Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
John Swinney Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Ruth Davidson Conservative Absent n/a
Sarah Boyack Labour No 100.00%
Jamie Halcro Johnston Conservative No 100.00%
Stuart McMillan Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Alexander Burnett Conservative No 100.00%
John Mason Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Jackson Carlaw Conservative No 100.00%
Lord Sarwar Labour No 100.00%
Mairi Gougeon Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Mary Fee Labour No 100.00%
Elizabeth Smith Conservative No 100.00%
Kevin Stewart Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
David Torrance Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Pauline McNeill Labour No 100.00%
Clare Adamson Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Alison Johnstone Green No 100.00%
Bill Kidd Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Linda Fabiani Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
David Stewart Labour No 100.00%
Michael Matheson Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Alex Cole-Hamilton Liberal Democrat No 100.00%
Graeme Dey Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Sandra White Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Jamie Hepburn Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Tom Arthur Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Jackie Baillie Labour No 100.00%
Kate Forbes Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Jeremy Balfour Conservative No 100.00%
Elaine Smith Labour No 100.00%
Gillian Martin Scottish National Party Aye 100.00%
Colin Smyth Labour No 100.00%
Maurice Golden Conservative No 100.00%
Derek Mackay Independent Absent n/a