Scottish Parliament – Feb. 17, 2021 – 1
Education
Result
❌ Motion failed.
Aye: 61 MSPs
No: 64 MSPs
Absent: 4 MSPs
Parliamentary analysis
Strong conflict: Gov proposesThis vote is most similar to a group of votes where the government is proposing a motion and the opposition is strongly opposing it (few defections, high turnout).
This usually suggests an important point of principle, that even if the government is likely to win, is a significant public signal of opposition.
Motion
Motion type: Other(?)
S5M-24137: That the Parliament believes that the support, services and decision-making provided by Education Scotland and the SQA have not met the expectations or requirements of hardworking teachers, pupils or parents throughout the disruption caused by the COVID-19 pandemic;
recalls that serious concerns existed about the performance and structure of these organisations for years before the pandemic struck, including those expressed by Parliament in its resolution on the debate on motion S5M-04920 on 29 March 2017;
considers that there is compelling evidence that neither body is fit for purpose and that they have lost the confidence of teachers, pupils and parents, and therefore calls for substantial reform as part of the recovery of education, with Education Scotland separated into independent inspection and policy functions and the SQA to be grounded in the teaching profession and made more accountable, and expresses concern about the reported involvement of both organisations and the Scottish Government in the ongoing OECD review.
Annotations
No annotations for this decision.
Whip reports
No whip reports for this decision.
Overall counts
| Grouping | MSPs on date | Vote participant count | For motion | Against motion | Absent motion | Turnout | For motion percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| All MSPs | 129 | 125 | 61 | 64 | 4 | 96.90% | 48.80% |
Government counts
| Grouping | MSPs on date | Vote participant count | For motion | Against motion | Absent motion | Turnout | For motion percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Opposition | 68 | 65 | 1 | 64 | 3 | 95.59% | 1.54% |
| Government | 61 | 60 | 60 | 0 | 1 | 98.36% | 100.00% |
Party voting counts
| Grouping | MSPs on date | Vote participant count | For motion | Against motion | Absent motion | Party turnout | For motion percentage |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Liberal Democrat | 5 | 5 | 0 | 5 | 0 | 100.00% | 0.00% |
| Independent | 3 | 2 | 1 | 1 | 1 | 66.67% | 50.00% |
| Green | 5 | 5 | 0 | 5 | 0 | 100.00% | 0.00% |
| Conservative | 30 | 29 | 0 | 29 | 1 | 96.67% | 0.00% |
| Reform UK | 1 | 1 | 0 | 1 | 0 | 100.00% | 0.00% |
| Labour | 24 | 23 | 0 | 23 | 1 | 95.83% | 0.00% |
| Scottish National Party | 61 | 60 | 60 | 0 | 1 | 98.36% | 100.00% |
Voting list
| Person | Party | Vote | Party alignment |
|---|---|---|---|
| Kenneth Macintosh | Labour | Absent | n/a |
| Margaret Mitchell | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Richard Lochhead | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alasdair Allan | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ash Denham | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| John Scott | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Miles Briggs | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Maree Todd | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Mark McDonald | Independent | Aye | n/a |
| Gail Ross | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Dean Lockhart | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| James Kelly | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Annie Wells | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Alex Neil | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Rachael Hamilton | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Aileen Campbell | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Roseanna Cunningham | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Kenneth Gibson | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Andy Wightman | Independent | No | n/a |
| Angus MacDonald | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Donald Cameron | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Christine Grahame | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Finlay Carson | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Richard Leonard | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Bob Doris | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Fiona Hyslop | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Humza Yousaf | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Willie Coffey | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Claire Baker | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Keith Brown | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Monica Lennon | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Christina McKelvie | Scottish National Party | Absent | n/a |
| Liam McArthur | Liberal Democrat | No | 100.00% |
| Willie Rennie | Liberal Democrat | No | 100.00% |
| Mark Griffin | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Johann Lamont | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Mike Rumbles | Liberal Democrat | No | 100.00% |
| Alex Rowley | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Patrick Harvie | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Mark Ruskell | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Michelle Ballantyne | Reform UK | No | 100.00% |
| Shirley-Anne Somerville | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ivan McKee | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Murdo Fraser | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Bruce Crawford | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jeane Freeman | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Neil Bibby | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Edward Mountain | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Clare Haughey | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ruth Maguire | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Colin Beattie | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Oliver Mundell | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Tom Mason | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Lewis Macdonald | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Fulton MacGregor | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Joan McAlpine | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Gil Paterson | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ben Macpherson | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Maurice Corry | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Daniel Johnson | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Joe FitzPatrick | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Gordon Lindhurst | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Beatrice Wishart | Liberal Democrat | No | 100.00% |
| Peter Chapman | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Maureen Watt | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Bill Bowman | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Emma Harper | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ross Greer | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Graham Simpson | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Rhoda Grant | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Alison Harris | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Richard Lyle | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Shona Robison | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Rona Mackay | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jenny Gilruth | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Adam Tomkins | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Angela Constance | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| George Adam | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| John Finnie | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Annabelle Ewing | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alexander Stewart | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Gordon MacDonald | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Stewart Stevenson | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Neil Findlay | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Nicola Sturgeon | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Claudia Beamish | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Jenny Marra | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Jamie Greene | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Brian Whittle | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Iain Gray | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Liam Kerr | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Paul Wheelhouse | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Michael Russell | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Fergus Ewing | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| James Dornan | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| John Swinney | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Ruth Davidson | Conservative | Absent | n/a |
| Sarah Boyack | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Jamie Halcro Johnston | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Stuart McMillan | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alexander Burnett | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| John Mason | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jackson Carlaw | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Lord Sarwar | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Mairi Gougeon | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Mary Fee | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Elizabeth Smith | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Kevin Stewart | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| David Torrance | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Pauline McNeill | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Clare Adamson | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alison Johnstone | Green | No | 100.00% |
| Bill Kidd | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Linda Fabiani | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| David Stewart | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Michael Matheson | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Alex Cole-Hamilton | Liberal Democrat | No | 100.00% |
| Graeme Dey | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Sandra White | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jamie Hepburn | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Tom Arthur | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jackie Baillie | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Kate Forbes | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Jeremy Balfour | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Elaine Smith | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Gillian Martin | Scottish National Party | Aye | 100.00% |
| Colin Smyth | Labour | No | 100.00% |
| Maurice Golden | Conservative | No | 100.00% |
| Derek Mackay | Independent | Absent | n/a |